Telluride Real Estate Q4 Market Report

Telluride Real Estate Q4 Market Report

The Prevailing Theme in 2023 Was Scarcity

In 2023, the prevailing theme for the Telluride Real Estate market was one of scarcity. Scarcity that emboldened Sellers and left many Buyers scratching their heads, even in the face of macroeconomic softening. The simple fact in Telluride is that we still have a significant lack of inventory for a consistent and even growing demand base. Consequently, Telluride area real estate values have largely returned to a steady rate of overall appreciation similar to pre-pandemic trends. The numbers bear this out: in 2023, San Miguel County’s total dollar volume was up 31% over 2019, despite 18% fewer transactions.

Buyers Have Continued to Find Value

The lack of inventory underlined a steep decline in number of transactions dropping from a total of 944 trades in 2021 to a modest 445 in 2023, a 53% drop. However, despite being less than half the number of transactions, dollar volume has only fallen 39% in 2023 from 2021. Clearly, Buyers have continued to find value in our market, many becoming happy owners understanding that the “top of the market” is nearly impossible to predict and of course, is always temporary.

Sophisticated Buyers in Telluride Want New, High-end Product

The aftereffects of 2 years of record absorption were evident and persistent throughout 2023. At the start of 2024, we only have 12 months’ worth of single-family home inventory between both the Town of Telluride and the Mountain Village. Condo inventory in Town is at a mere 50% of what the market demanded in 2023, while Mountain Village inventory stands minimally at 33%. Meanwhile, new construction and recently remodeled inventory continues to drive values higher at the upper end. The trend is evident: sophisticated buyers in Telluride want new, high-end product and are willing to pay the necessary premiums for it.

Looking forward, what is the ultimate result of this protracted period of low inventory? The opportunity and advent of new product in our market.

Projects Provide a Spectrum of Impending Options

Projects including the Four Seasons Telluride Private Residences, Mountain Village’s forthcoming Highline Residences, and the Post Office Lot/Telluride Hotel & Residences in the Town of Telluride (even potentially the TKV project near the Gondola) provide a spectrum of impending options for a broad demographic of Buyers. This is all in addition to a multitude of single-family spec product that continues to trickle to market. On a large scale, it has been a long time since we have had new development projects in Telluride and the new pricing that comes with these projects is well in-line with comparable products in similar resorts. With this higher level of finish, property values will continue to elevate Telluride to the proper place near the top of North American Ski Resorts.

Telluride Remains One of the Most Desirable Communities

Values, appreciation, and future growth notwithstanding, Telluride remains one of the most desirable locales and communities in the world. Even if all the proposed development inventory is brought to the market, the maximum capacity of the immediate Telluride area will only increase fractionally. Over the holidays, peak ski days were enjoyed with no lift lines, while comparable resorts saw hours-long wait times. Telluride is poised to remain an exclusive and community-centric club for those with the forethought and passion to thoughtfully invest for their happiness and enjoyment.

Want more personalized details about your real estate search? We can help. Whether you’re looking for more insight about the current real estate market or simply want some local tips about the best ski runs, don’t hesitate to contact us or start your search now! We’d love to show you around.
Shimmy and Asa Signature



Connect With Us on Social!

Let Us Help You Find Your Dream Home

Related Posts

Sunny, exterior view of real estate listing 135 Marmot Way Ophir (Trout Lake), with decks, forest and blue skies

Just Listed: 135 Marmot Way, Ophir (Trout Lake)

This recently remodeled Trout Lake, Colorado haven borders an old-growth conifer forest, while majestic alpine peaks and the sparkling Trout Lake lie just beyond. Nestled within walking distance of the lake, this dream retreat offers nearly 2,800 sf of inviting living space.

Summer aerial view of Rico, Colorado real estate listing 15322 Road 55.9 with two homes on wooded property.

Just Listed: 15322 Road 55.9, Rico, CO

This Rico, Colorado property boasts 3+ acres with mature Aspen and Spruce trees supports and 3 structures to fuel your outdoor passions: an energy-efficient home w/sizeable decks and expansive windows, a garage/shop with a studio, full bath and oversized carport, and a whimsical 2022 yurt ideal for guests or workouts.

Summer aerial view of real estate listing Lot 628H Double Eagle Way, Mountain Village with golf fairway nearby.

Just Listed: Lot 628H Double Eagle Way, Mountain Village

This is one of the best lots on the Telluride Golf Course with end of cul-de-sac privacy and adjacent abundant open space spilling down to the fringe of the 4th green. Just a one-minute drive to the lifts. Directly adjacent to the Telluride Nordic trail.

Have a Question?

We'd Love to Help

Shimkonis Partners